Most SEO competitor analyses fail in one of two ways. They name the wrong competitors, usually the businesses the owner worries about rather than the sites that actually take the clicks. Or they collect piles of data and never decide what to do with it. This guide fixes both. It walks through seven steps and ends with a calculator that ranks the opportunities you find.
It is built from the searches people make most, such as "seo competitor analysis", "competitor analysis for seo", "seo competitor analysis template", "seo competitor analysis report", "free seo competitor analysis tools", "how to do competitor analysis in seo" and "seo competitor analysis checklist", and from published guides by Semrush, Moz and Search Engine Land plus Google's own documentation.
What is SEO competitor analysis?
An SEO competitor analysis is research into the sites that rank for the searches you want, to learn what they target, how they structure content, who links to them and where they are weak. Moz frames the goal as reverse engineering the most successful elements of competitors' tactics instead of guessing which keywords, content and links to pursue.
Two things matter before you start. First, "competitor" means a site that competes for the search result, not necessarily one that competes for the customer. Second, the output should be decisions. If your report does not tell someone what to publish, fix or earn next week, it is not finished.
The seven steps at a glance
Step 1. Find your real SEO competitors
Search your ten most important keywords and write down every domain that appears in the top results. Semrush suggests using the same keywords on Google, YouTube, AI platforms and Reddit, so you are not limited to one platform. Then confirm with a tool. In Semrush, the Domain Overview report lists "Main Organic Competitors", the domains ranking for many of the same keywords, with common keyword counts. Search Engine Land makes the same point and suggests collecting at least four or five.
Aim for three to five competitors to start. That is enough data without drowning in it. Split them into three groups:
| Type | Example | How to use them |
|---|---|---|
| Direct business rivals | Another agency, clinic or shop in your market | Offer, pricing, local presence, reviews |
| Search-only rivals | Publishers, directories, comparison sites | Content formats, topics, link sources |
| Aspirational leaders | The site that dominates the whole topic | Topical coverage and what great looks like |
Search-only rivals are the surprise for most owners. If review sites and listicles fill page one, you cannot beat them by writing the same listicle. You may need a different angle, a stronger local page or a tool they do not have.
Step 2. Run a keyword gap analysis
A keyword gap analysis compares the keywords your competitors rank for with yours. It shows where you are missing, where you are weaker and where you already lead. Moz describes it as finding terms competitors rank for that your site does not, so you can capture a broader audience.
How to filter a gap report
- Keep keywords where at least two competitors rank in the top 20 and you do not.
- Remove terms with the wrong intent, for example "jobs" or "free templates" when you sell services.
- Group the rest by topic so each group becomes one page or cluster, not twenty thin pages.
- Note the search intent for each group: informational, comparison, local or purchase.
- Check for cannibalisation before creating pages. See keyword cannibalization.
Step 3. Reverse engineer your competitors' best pages
Traffic analysis shows which pages drive the most visits to each rival. Open the top five pages for each and record the angle, structure and format. Semrush suggests asking whether the page takes a strong position or a neutral overview, who it is written for, how it is structured (map the H2s), and which formats it uses, such as comparison tables, step-by-step processes, original data or proprietary frameworks. If several high-ranking pages share a structure, that structure is likely what Google is rewarding. Do not copy it blindly.
| Page element | Record for each competitor page | Your opportunity |
|---|---|---|
| Angle | Audience, stance, depth | A sharper audience or fresher view |
| Headings | H2 list, questions answered | Questions they skip |
| Format | Tables, tools, video, calculators | A tool or dataset they lack |
| Evidence | Sources, first-hand examples, dates | Verified, current facts |
| Freshness | Last updated date | Beat stale pages with a real update |
| Length | Word count | More usefulness, not just more words |
Google's guidance on people-first content asks whether a page gives original information, analysis or a substantial, complete description of the topic. Use that as your bar when you plan something better than the page in position one.
Step 4. Compare backlink profiles
Backlinks are still one of the strongest differences between sites that rank and sites that do not. Semrush recommends first looking at link trends to see how rivals earn links, then running a backlink gap analysis to find domains that link to competitors but not to you.
- Export referring domains for each competitor.
- Keep domains that link to two or more competitors and not to you.
- Sort them by type: news, industry directories, resource pages, partners, universities and communities.
- Match each type to a tactic, such as a data study, a resource-page pitch or a partnership.
- Look at which of their pages earn the most links. That is a content idea with proof of demand.
Our guide to backlink types helps match each source to a method.
Step 5. Check technical and experience factors
Technical analysis rarely produces wins on its own, but it finds problems that cap everything else. Compare you and your rivals on:
- Whether key pages are crawlable and indexable, and how sitemaps and internal links are set up.
- Page experience, including Core Web Vitals from Google's own tools.
- Mobile usability and intrusive pop-ups.
- Site structure, URL patterns and how deep important pages sit.
- Structured data in use and which rich results it earns.
Google's SEO starter guide is a reliable checklist for the basics. Use it to judge whether a competitor's advantage is technical or just content and links.
Step 6. Review local SEO and AI search visibility
Local SEO
If you serve a geographic area, Semrush advises reviewing each direct competitor's Google Business Profile, reviews and local search visibility. Check categories, photos, review count and recency, and what customers praise or complain about. Log who shows up and where for the searches that matter to you.
AI search
Semrush and Search Engine Land both now fold AI platforms into the process. Run your target questions in AI answer tools, note which competitors are named, who is listed first and how each business is summarised. Then look at what those pages have in common, usually clear answers, strong third-party mentions and consistent facts. Our guide to generative engine optimization covers the tactics.
Step 7. Score and prioritise the opportunities
Now turn findings into a ranked list. For each opportunity estimate monthly traffic, how much of it you can win, how many visitors become leads or sales, and what each is worth. Then divide by effort. The calculator does the arithmetic.
SEO gap opportunity calculator
Run it for each topic group and sort by the 12-month multiple. Remember that rankings take time and are not guaranteed, so treat the output as a way to compare options, not a forecast.
| Score | Action type | Typical order |
|---|---|---|
| High value, low effort | Update a page that already ranks 4 to 15, fill missing questions | First |
| High value, high effort | New pillar page, original data study, tool | Plan and schedule |
| Low value, low effort | Small fixes, internal links, titles | Batch together |
| Low value, high effort | Chasing a rival's keyword with the wrong intent | Skip |
SEO competitor analysis template
Copy this structure into a spreadsheet. Moz and Semrush also publish free templates you can adapt.
| Tab | Columns |
|---|---|
| Competitors | Domain, type, why they compete, organic traffic estimate, common keywords |
| Keyword gap | Keyword, volume, intent, your rank, rival ranks, bucket, topic group |
| Top pages | URL, topic, angle, format, word count, updated date, estimated traffic |
| Backlink gap | Referring domain, type, links to which rival, contact, tactic |
| Technical and local | Check, you, rival A, rival B, notes |
| AI search | Prompt, platform, who is named, order, sources cited |
| Action plan | Action, topic group, value, effort, owner, due date, result |
What an SEO competitor analysis report includes
- Summary. Three to five findings and the actions they lead to.
- Who you are up against. Competitor list with reasons.
- Keyword and content gaps. Topic groups with volume and intent.
- Backlink gaps. Source types and tactics.
- Technical, local and AI findings. Only the items that change a decision.
- Prioritised plan. The calculator output, ordered, with owners and dates.
- How you will measure it. Rankings, clicks, leads and links, reviewed monthly.
A sample finding reads: "Two competitors rank in the top five for 'emergency plumber [city]' with dedicated service pages and 24-hour schedules. We have one general plumbing page. Action: build a dedicated emergency page, add schedule and reviews, link from the home page. Estimated value $X a month, effort two days." Short, specific and ready to do.
SEO competitor analysis tools
| Need | Options | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Competitor and keyword gaps | Semrush, Ahrefs, Moz, SE Ranking | Check current plan limits and databases |
| Your own data | Google Search Console, Google Analytics | Free, and the most accurate for your site |
| Search results | Google, YouTube, AI answer tools, Reddit | Free, and shows real features and formats |
| Technical checks | A site crawler, PageSpeed Insights | Compare you against rivals page by page |
| Backlinks | Backlink databases in the tools above | Link counts differ by tool |
Free tiers change often, so verify what you get before building a process around them. A free workflow still works: use Search Console for your queries, search results for competitors and formats, and a spreadsheet for the gaps.
Common mistakes
- Choosing competitors by gut. Use the results pages and a tool.
- Copying structure and length. You need a better answer, not a longer one.
- Chasing every gap keyword. Filter by intent and value.
- Ignoring your own Search Console data. Pages at positions 4 to 15 are often your fastest wins.
- Treating it as a one-off. Moz stresses it is an ongoing process.
- Skipping the plan. No owners and dates means no results.
- Forgetting AI answers. Visibility there now needs tracking too.
SEO competitor analysis checklist
- Three to five competitors chosen from real results and a tool
- Keyword gap filtered by intent and grouped by topic
- Top competitor pages mapped by angle, headings and format
- Backlink gap sorted by source type and tactic
- Technical, local and AI search comparisons done
- Opportunities scored with the calculator
- Action plan with owners and dates
- Monthly light review scheduled and full review twice a year
Need help turning the findings into published pages and links? See our SEO and AI search optimisation service.
Sources
- Semrush: How to do an SEO competitor analysis. www.semrush.com
- Moz: How to do an SEO competitor analysis. moz.com
- Search Engine Land: How to conduct an AI and SEO competitor analysis. searchengineland.com
- Google Search Central: SEO starter guide. developers.google.com
- Google Search Central: Creating helpful, reliable, people-first content. developers.google.com
- Google Search Console Help: Performance report. support.google.com